Home Page > HNV farming in Scotland > HNV Parliamentary Event – Scotland (June 2013)

Vulnerable Farming Areas (VFA) Event at Scottish Parliament

5th June 2013

Rob Gibson MSP

Rob Gibson MSP

Rob Gibson, MSP for Caithness, Sutherland and Ross and Convenor of the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and the Environment Committee, hosted a VFA farming event at Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh with RSPB Scotland and the Highlands and Islands Agriculture Steering Group to highlight the concerns for Scotland’s most vulnerable farming areas to MSPs and key stakeholders.
Rob started the event with some thought provoking quotes from E F Schumacher.

Douglas Irvine

Douglas Irvine

Douglas Irvine from Shetland Isles, summarised the economic and social challenges in the agricultural sector for the Highlands and Islands (mainly sheep & cattle farming systems).
Facts & figures from Highlands & Islands:

  • 23,454 individual holdings covering 3.3 million ha land
  • 30% sheep production in Scotland
  • 20% cattle production in Scotland

Douglas made a case to the Scottish Government, UK & EU for a more equitable system of support in Scotland and to improve the levels of support for those in the VFA, to reverse some of the trends happening now, such as whole scale abandonment of land, loss of full time agricultural workers (32% decline between 1990-2010) and livestock decline from these areas (since 2005 – 23% fall in breeding sheep/ 9% decline in breeding cattle).

There was a call for Scotland to receive an increase in share of EU Rural Development funds, and that the Scottish Rural Development Programme (SRDP) 2014-2020 should set objective targets to support agriculture in these Vulnerable Farming Areas.
Reference was made to a Scottish Natural Heritage paper: “An analysis of the impact on natural heritage of the decline in hill farming in Scotland” June 2011

Stuart Housden

Stuart Housden

Stuart Housden, Director of RSPB Scotland, continued to highlight how important HNV farming systems are for biodiversity and wider ecosystem services for society but that these are currently unrewarded by the markets.
40% of Scotland’s Utilisable Agricultural Area (UAA) is HNV farming, with reference made to HNV farmer Andrew Elliott at Balnakeil and the importance of the machair on the Outer Hebrides for species such as corncrake, corn bunting and Greater yellow bumblesbee.

Maps were shown indicating the disparity of distribution of support (Single Farm Payment & Rural Priorities) across Scotland, favouring the east of the country.

Stuart called for:

  • Regionalised payments should increase to support HNV farmers to recognise the public goods they support
  • Maximise modulation from Pillar1 1 to Pillar 2
  • Set clear objectives & targets in SRDP
  • Improve targeting of Less Favoured Areas Support Scheme/ Areas of Natural Constraint to HNV areas
  • Increase agri-environment scheme support & improve targeting to HNV farmers & crofters
  • Use of Intereg/ EU LIFE to support community led initiatives
  • Identify & monitor HNV systems

As Stuart concluded “These are fantastic assets that we manage, those who live, work and manage these landscapes should be duly rewarded to ensure they are passed onto the younger generation.”

Presentations were followed by a Question and Answer session which raised a number of key issues:

  • The importance of maintaining activity – allsorts of benefits depend on farming/crofting activity being maintained. Pillar I support is important but difficult to attach conditionality that is not blunt e.g. minimum stocking density requirements which could be too high/too low depending on the site. Broad agreement that proposal to exempt farmers/crofters receiving less than €5,000 from activity would be unhelpful and send wrong signals.
  • Abandonment must be avoided – need to ensure a managed landscape with an infrastructure of farmers in place which ensures activity, skills and knowledge are retained. Greater effort required to help young farmers and new entrants.
  • Need to ensure viable farming businesses/crofting – greater investment required in Pillar II measures which enable targeting to achieve desired outcomes. Advice needs to be built into packages of support.
  • Next SRDP needs clear objectives – and these must include support for Vulnerable/High Nature Value farming areas.

Scottish Parliament flagsdiscussion session



Photo credits: Deborah Deveney